It is generally (but not universally!) accepted that fish will do better in an aquarium if some of the water is drained upon occasion and replaced with new clean water. This is called a “water change”. People drain and refill anywhere from 75% of the aquarium twice a week to 10% of the aquarium every month. Some never change the water and do just fine. Mother Nature is much more forgiving than the well meaning but ill-informed individuals on social media would have us believe.
A reasonable water change schedule for most hobbyists is:
Now this is a generalized guideline based on how typical stocking and feeding. We recommend only a greater than 50% water change every two weeks if heavily stocked; every six weeks if moderately stocked, and every five months if lightly stocked. And even these recommendations can be violated pretty much with impunity. Water changes are just not anywhere near as important as social media would have one believe.
There is some myths about water changes. Several of those myths have to do with a common occurrence with ALL water supplies which are chlorinated. Water suppliers can do something called “chlorine pulse”. Sometimes water suppliers put up to 4 ppm chlorine in the water. The normal dose of conditioner will neutralize 1 ppm. That leaves 3 ppm to kill the fish.
The water used for large water changes can have three different problems which kill fish, “chlorine pulse”, low oxygen levels or high carbon dioxide levels. When someone loses a lot of fish after a water change, it is human nature to find something “at fault”. Since by the time the fish die the chlorine, oxygen or carbon dioxide levels have returned to safe levels in the aquarium, people look for something else. So it becomes “nitrate shock”, “pH shock”, “KH shock”, “temperature shock” etc. etc. ad infinitum. These are all myths.
There are a few very common myths about water changes:
- Large scale water changes (40% to 95%) kill fish.
- Changing water with water even a few degrees difference from the aquarium water will “shock” the fish and may kill them.
- Changing water with water of a different Nitrate, pH, GH or KH level will “shock” fish and may kill them.
The Profit Motive
There are a host of charts and websites which say one should do a 50% water change once a week in order to have healthy fish. Everyone, and I mean EVERYONE, on social media parrots these recommendations, including your local fish store. Some simple calculations say that the market for aquarium water conditioners is about $150 million if hobbyists do 50% water changes once a week.
If typical hobbyists only change the water when the nitrate level goes to 80 ppm, or once every six weeks, then the yearly market for conditioners is only $25 million. So that basically is 125 million reasons for the 50% once a week recommendations. Isn’t the profit motive great?
There are a large number of charts on social media which are simply laughable. One is this:
This simply is a horribly misleading chart which grossly overstates the toxicity of water parameters, especially about the toxicity as it relates to pH. If everyone followed this chart the hobby wouldn’t last a year because everyone would be doing such frequent water changes they would give up the hobby. But conditioner suppliers like Seachem would make a whole lot of money. Knowing this a very skeptical person might well question the origins of the graph above. hhhmmm…..
|pH of the water||API Ammonia test in ppm||API nitrite test in ppm|
|Nitrate alarm level is greater than 80 ppm.
Nitrate toxic level is greater than 440 ppm.
In actuality the toxicity of ammonia and nitrite is very dependent on pH so one has to measure the pH with a test kit to determine if a water change is recommended. Then the proper recommendation is below.
This is a magnitude of difference from the Master Test Kit chart so prevalent on social media. The levels on this chart are the safety levels per many research papers on the topic from the likes of the Ornamental Fish Research Center at the University of Florida. These number are solid, VERY solid.
To use this chart one must first measure the pH of the aquarium (Note the API “Low pH” test is only good from 6.0 to 7.2 and the “high pH” test is only good for 7.2 to 8.6). Find that pH in the left most column. Then simply read across as to the various levels that the API test will give for ammonia and nitrite. For instance, if the pH of your aquarium is 7.8 and the API test kit says you have 4 parts per million ammonia, you need to do a 50% water change.
For those doubters who want back up to these numbers, the research papers on ammonia can be found at this link:
The back up research papers on nitrite can be found at this link:
The back up research papers on nitrate can be found at this link:
The author has been in the hobby fifty years. The first fifteen years the going philosophy was that “old” water was “good” water. We never, and we mean NEVER, did a water change. And our fish were healthy and appeared to be long lived, at least many of them reached sizes we hadn’t been expecting.
For another fifteen years or so the mantra was 25% water changes every month. If you do the math, this 25% water change has little impact. And still the fish prospered. Mother Nature is simple very flexible and very forgiving. There are many ways to be successful with an aquarium.
There is a famous fish store in San Francisco which has NEVER done a water change on any of its what appears to be about fifty aquariums. Their tanks are filled with a lot of very sensitive fish like Rams and Apistos. They are all doing fine, even breeding. Some of their aquariums have gone twenty years with no water change. Aquarium Co-op has a YouTube video on the store. They raise and sell plants and fish and the masses of vegetation and fish sold remove all the nitrogen and phosphorus.
Speed of Water Changes
Water changes can be very time consuming. Most home aquarists drain the water by a siphon hose into buckets. Then they refill the tank with buckets. This is very time consuming and hobbyists are always looking at ways to improve the process.
There are several devices like the python which hook up to a sink and both drain the water from the aquarium and refill the aquarium with water. These devices have several obvious problems. First off one needs to get a good seal on the faucet for these devices to work. Most faucets do not allow this. So on social media one constantly sees the question “How the *&XX*** Hell**%$%^&*#” do I attach this Python to my faucet“. And 90% of the time the answer will be “You can’t“.
The other problem with pythons is that the draining operation is very wasteful of water. For every gallon one drains one is probably putting five gallons down the drain. If one has a small aquarium this is not a problem. But a large aquarium or multiple aquariums can get up there in water costs.
HalfMan/HalfCichlid recommends adding a pump in the aquarium with a hose to a sink to rapidly drain the water. This is an excellent idea and easy to implement. I heartily recommend it to anyone with lots of aquariums or a very large aquarium.
Water Changes in More Depth
To read more about water changes click on the following links: