Small aquarium gravel turns out to be a reasonably good filter media. If one fills a canister with bags of cheap aquarium gravel the canister will be a much better filter than say a canister filled with expensive ceramic media. This is very surprising but it is true!
The data in the biomedia master table for aquarium gravel is based on:
Considering that small gravel can be sometimes obtained quite inexpensively, small gravel (must be smaller than a quarter of an inch) can be a very price effective filter media. While the surface area is half that of pot scrubbers or static K1, the cost can sometimes be as low as one tenth on a volume basis. This makes just good old small aquarium gravel a very good media for large sumps and even large canisters if cost is important to the hobbyist.
|Biomedia||Effective” surface area ft²/ft³||Effective” surface area m²/m³||Cubic inches to get 5ft²||Cubic inches to get 100ft²|
|Fluidized K1 media (60% loading in sump)||540||16||320|
|30 PPI foam in canister or sump||340||25||500|
|30 PPI foam powerhead operated sponge||340||25||500|
|30 PPI foam air operated sponge||300||29||580|
|Plastic pot scrubbers||280||31||620|
|Static K1 media||260||33||660|
|20 PPI foam in canister or sump||260||33||660|
|20 PPI foam powerhead operated sponge||260||33||660|
|20 PPI foam air operated sponge||230||38||751|
|Powerhead operated undergravel filter||140||62||1240|
|Aquarium gravel in canister or sump||140||62||1240|
|Air operated undergravel filter||120||72||1440|
|Blue Matala pads||120||72||1440|
|1/8 inch garden pumice or perlite||100||86||1720|
|1/2 inch lava rock||60||144||2880|
|Expanded clay pebbles||30||288||5760|
|Cubic inches to get 5ft² = (5/E.A.)x1,728 100ft²=(100/E.A.x1,728)|
Calcined clay is what some kitty litters and some oil absorbents are made of. The biggest reason people might choose to use calcined clay over a traditional aquarium filter media is that it’s much cheaper. Calcined clay will be the equivalent of aquarium gravel in the list above, which makes it probably the most cost-effective filter media that there is.
Some cat litters are not calcined (fired) sufficiently to maintain structural integrity (hardness) under water for long durations of time – in other words they turn to mush. Any clumping cat litter will turn to mush. A much better option is to use an oil absorber found in the automotive hardware section of the store. Safe-t-sorb from Tractor Supply is incredibly cheap and very effective as a media. It maintains its structure and does not “break down” into mush.
All calcined clay products will be very dusty, and the first use will require a lot of rinsing.
Gravel in Under-Gravel Filters
Note gravel is very useful in under-gravel filters. And contrary to all the barrage of negative comments from well meaning but ill informed commentators, under-gravel filters work very well. An air operated under gravel filter will give a biofiltration capacity of roughly 150 square feet per cubic feet of gravel. A powerhead operated high flow under-gravel filter will give an effective biofiltration capacity of about 180 feet squared per cubic foot of gravel.
More about under-gravel filters can be found at this line:
ALL under-gravel filters work very well simply because there is such a large volume of media if the gravel is one to two inches deep over the under gravel filter. Under gravel filters work very well IF AND ONLY IF they are not frequently cleaned. I use under gravel filters in ALL my non-planted fish only tanks (16 last count) in addition to other filters such as sumps. I love under-gravel filters.
Aquarium gravel doesn’t have the ability to aerate water well in a trickle or wet/dry filter, so it can’t be used there. What is missed here is that aquarium gravel is very effective in bags in a canister or in bags in a submerged media sump filter. It is the easiest media to use, one of the cheapest and one of the most effective. And no one uses it. The power of the modern marketing machine and the profit motive at work.
Many filters use activated carbon in bags or beds. If this carbon is changed frequently it is relatively useless for biofiltration. If it is left in place for two weeks or more its tiny pores clog up and it becomes simply a biomedia covered in beneficial bacteria. It then has a purpose equivalent to what aquarium gravel will do.
Is a Gravel Substrate Effective as a Biofilter?
When aquarium gravel is used simply as a substrate it can act as ineffective biofilter, even if it is not setup as an under-gravel. The ammonia filled water diffuses in and out of the substrate slowly and allows bacteria on the surface of the substrate to remove some small amounts of ammonia. But without an under-gravel filter the flow of the water is too low to do really good biofiltration. But the surface area is so great that gravel substrate can still do some very limited biofiltration.
Testing showed that a gravel substrate can remove about 25% of the ammonia that a sponge filter can remove. This testing can be found at this link: