Post is published, publicly visible.
Translated in Dutch by Joost Abrahams
Proofread by John de Lange

1.5. Aquarium Options

Photo of author

Author : David Bogert

Published :

Time To Read :
3 minutes
Difficulty : Level 4

Excerpt :

The "type" of aquarium one decides to have can be split into six different methodologies, three "fish only" and three planted.
There are about as many “correct” ways to keep fish thriving in an aquarium as there are aquarium keepers. It is not an exact demarcation. And Mother Nature is extremely flexible.

But the aquarium options can be divided into six very broad options. Here are three “fish-only” aquarium options:

Fish-only parameterLghtly stockedBreederHeavily stocked
Fish stockingLightLightHeavy
PlantsNoneNone to moderateNone
Typical substrateSand or gravelBare bottomSand or gravel
AerationModerateHeavyHeavy
LightingAnyAnyAny
Typical water changes25% every month25% every other week50% every other week
BiofiltrationLightModerateVery Heavy
Degree of difficultyEasyModerateModerate
Beginner Aquarium
Beginner Aquarium with Largely Fish

And here are three planted aquarium options:

Parameter“low-tech” or “Walstad”planted“high-tech” plantedMany fish, many plants
Fish stockingLightVery LightModerate
PlantsHeavyHeavyModerate
Typical substrateGarden soil with capCommercial fused productVarious
AerationLightLightHeavy
LightingModerate 4 on 4 offHighHigh
CO²NoYesYes
FertilizationNoYesHeavy
Typical water changes50% every four monthNever25% every other week
BiofiltrationLightLightHeavy
Degree of difficultyModerateDifficultVery Difficult

All six of these types of aquariums are “correct” and have an infinite number of variations.

Tolerance is in very short supply in today’s world. This intolerance extends to keeping aquariums. If you read the forums and groups on the internet there is a constant barrage of “no, you can’t” rather than “you will have challenges but have at it”. An aquarium is a natural system and Mother Nature is extremely flexible. So if you have an idea for an aquarium, go for it!

Beginner Aquarium
Beginner Largely Planted Aquarium

Now I will go ahead and do exactly what I hate, namely try to caution one against one type of aquarium. Unfortunately, many newcomers to the hobby buy both a moderate amount of decent sized fish and a moderate amount of plants to start their hobby. This is one of the most difficult aquariums to keep. Generally, the plants die and in rare cases, the fish die, and the newcomer gives up the hobby. Newcomers should skip the plants and start with a lightly stocked “fish only” aquarium with several small fish and plastic plants till they get to understand the hobby better. But if you like a challenge go ahead and try it.

If one wants plants with their fish some plants are the exception and simply can’t be killed and which seem to live under any conditions. While they will get some algae on their leaves the leaves are resistant to being smothered by algae. And they seem to live in all substrates under all conditions with no fertilizer at all. They even live in very low light conditions.

Low Tech Planted Aquarium
Low Tech Planted Aquarium

The plants that seem to fit this description are Anubias (just don’t put the bulbs INTO the substrate), Amazon Sword (Echinodorus amazonicus), Java Fern (Leptochilus pteropus, synonym Microsorum pteropus), and Java Moss (Taxiphyllum barbieri). Java fern and Java moss are both “epiphytes” and need to be either attached to a surface like a piece of wood or they need a very open substrate like aquarium gravel. If you bury the crown on Java fern in sand it will die.

In the aquarium below note a large number of fish and a large number of plants. Also, note the cloudiness of the water and the scum on the water’s surface. I would predict these fish and these plants will not live long. But I could well be completely wrong!

Beginner Fish and Plant Aquarium
Beginner Fish and Plant Aquarium

To see photos of many types of Aquariums one can load the following link (note the file is large and takes a long time to load)

1.5.1. Aquarium Examples