There are two low tech CO₂ systems extant. One, an inverted bottle diffuser, is for ONLY small low tech tanks under 20 gallons (80 liters). The second, a “wide mouthed jar” diffuser, will work well for much larger aquariums. These type systems are often called “passive CO₂ bottles”.
Bottle Diffuser for Small Aquariums
There is a type of low-tech, low-cost CO₂ “passive CO₂ bottle” diffuser system for ONLY low tech planted aquariums under twenty gallons. These type systems add small amounts of CO₂ to an aquarium that should have only low intensity lights over a span of 8 hours per day or so. These diffuser systems will NOT feed enough CO₂ for a high tech tank with high intensity light for say 14 hours per day. A variation of it was used with yeast CO₂ generators way back in the 1980s.
Commercial systems which use this system are the ista CO₂ Starter Kit, Fluval CO₂ Kit, and the Tropical CO₂ System 60. Then there are a whole host of DIY designs that can be found on YouTube. These various systems should be considered as alternative systems to a dirted or Walstad aquarium as they will only push the CO₂ to a low level, just like a dirted tank. Contrary to the elitists in the aquascaping hobby, these kit are VERY useful in small aquariums and very safe for fish.
An DIY version of this system is used by Mr. Justin Hau at a small local fish store in San Francisco by the name Ocean Aquarium. The Ocean Aquarium store has a whole bunch of small ten-gallon low-tech low-light (8 hours max, no crimson or blue LEDs) freshwater aquariums filled with gorgeous plants and small fish. The store caters to nano aquarium enthusiasts (most landlords in San Francisco limit aquarium size to a maximum of ten gallons due to earthquakes).
Mr. Hau uses a small (Tippmann Paintball 20oz CO₂ Air Tank, $29) CO₂ pressurized tank to fill small narrow mouthed water bottles floating in his small tanks with CO₂ every few days. He uses a plastic tube formed into a “J” to do the filling.
The CO₂ dissolves slowly in the small amount of water which slowly swirls around the SMALL bottle opening. This results in a SMALL amount of CO₂ going into the aquarium. This SMALL amount of CO₂ nourishes a lush growth of largely low tech “green” plants. Note that the size of the bottle opening directly determines the amount of CO₂ that goes into the aquarium. While a wide mouth will NOT add too much CO₂, it will result in the CO₂ being rapidly depleted from the bottle.
This system is very attractive as it can be done very cheaply. And another attraction is that one cannot kill fish with this system. It is impossible to add too much CO₂ with these systems.
Mr. Hau’s CO₂ system is easily changed into a low-tech system that simply uses any one of several CO₂ generating systems to supply the CO₂. With a simple yeast generating bottle the system looks like this:
The diffuser bottle that is in the aquarium is secured to the side of the aquarium with tape or wire (Mr. Hau just lets them float tethered to the side of the aquarium). This inside-the-aquarium bottle does not have a cap on it. The inside-the-aquarium bottle weights the neck to keep its neck down in the water even when filled with CO₂.
Mr. Hau uses a rock held on with wire. I found some large steel nuts at Ace hardware that screws on the top of a water bottle. One can also weigh the neck down by wrapping silicone-coated lead weight strips such as are used to weigh down aquarium plants. The two commercial kits are very good options. They use suction cups to hold to the side of the aquarium.
A third way to secure the bottle of CO₂ down inside the aquarium is to use a big lead fishing weight (the lead is harmless to the fish). They make them up to half a pound in size. Simply wrap a steel wire around the neck of the bottle and then run the wire through the grommets on the weight. One can also drill holes in the bottle and run wire through those holes.
It should be noted that even a small bottle filled with air is VERY buoyant. So it is best just to tether it to the side and let it float up and down. As long as the water level in the bottle is lower than the water level in the tank, all will be fine. This is true even if that level is only one eighth of an inch lower.
Thread the tubing into the bottle and secure the tubing so it can’t come out of the bottle. The inside-the-aquarium bottle then needs to be filled with water so that there is little to no air in it when it is secured into its position. Note Mr. Hau uses no airline into the bottles, just filling them with a “J” tube when needed.
Then attach the tube to a CO₂ generating system. I’ve just shown a single bottle outside the aquarium to illustrate the system. Obviously if one chooses to duplicate the way Mr. Hau fills the inside-the-aquarium bottle there will be no outside bottle. The outside bottle in this diagram is simply representative of any one of the following CO₂ generating systems:
- Disposable CO₂ containers (ista CO₂ Starter Kit, Fluval CO₂ kit or the Tropica CO₂ System 60)
- yeast and sugar system (cost ranges from $5 for simple DIY systems to $80 for complex systems)
- pressurized baking soda and citric acid (cost ranges from $30 for DIY systems to $150 for complex systems)
- paintball CO₂ systems (cost ranges from $30 to $150)
- large pressurized CO₂ systems (price ranges from $100 to $500)
There are a whole bunch of very good videos on YouTube about each of these systems. So I won’t try to explain them. My personal favorite is simply a cheap DIY yeast/sugar two bottle generating system with no valves or regulators. Two bottles, some tubing, and some silicone. Simple and easy. It does need to be refilled about once every two to four weeks. But that is easy. The key is that yeast works pretty slow at the temperature of most homes.
It is also very easy to simply use Mr. Hau’s method (see the Aquarium Co-op video on it). Simply put a flow valve and tubing on a pressurized tank (Paintball Air Tank) with a plastic tube bent in a “J” to allow going inside the neck of the bottle in the aquarium. Simply do what Mr. Hau does, namely, fill the bottle with CO₂ whenever the amount of gas in the bottle becomes low or disappears (this should be every one to two days). Easy.
Now for a small aquarium (under ten gallons, 37,8 liter), a small soda bottle inside the aquarium will do the trick very well. For a larger tank (up to twenty gallons, 75,7 liter), one can use a larger bottle or even two bottles.
When there is no gas left in the system the bottle in the aquarium will show the aquarium water filling the bottle IF the bottle is completely submerged in the aquarium. It is important to use a bottle where the size of the mouth is proportional to the tank size. A five gallon (18,9 liter) will need a small mouthed bottle. A fifteen gallon (56,7 liter) will need a wider mouth. Note anything over twenty gallons (75,7 liter) should have a constant CO₂ set up with a jar diffuser (see below).
One reader used an ista CO₂ Starter Kit (4 cm diameter opening) on a 100 gallon (378.5 liter) aquarium. The gas in the bottle dissipated in three to four hours and put 10 to 15 ppm CO₂ into the aquarium. Hooking an ista up to a continuous CO₂ generator or tank would give a decent level of CO₂ in a 100 gallon (378.5 liter),
Mr. Hau has aquariums with literally NO water flow in them. If one has ANYTHING which produces a water flow across the mouth of the bottle, even a small water flow, the bottle opening will need to be closed down. A metal cap can have a hole drilled in it and put on the bottle in an aquarium with some flow of the water.
Note that any decent flow at the surface of the aquarium will remove the CO₂ from the aquarium as fast as one can put it in. So Mr. Hau’s method will NOT work with any decent water flow on the surface of the aquarium.
To speed up the dissipation and increase the CO₂ levels, drill a small hole or holes in the neck of the bottle in the aquarium. To slow down the dissipation and decrease the CO₂ levels, simply cover a small portion of the opening of the bottle in the aquarium with some tape.
Note that this system is very safe and will not create a dangerous level of CO₂ in the aquarium. So no expensive regulators or measuring devices are needed. This is also a very cheap system to operate.
An Alternative Diffuser System for Larger Tanks
Let us say you have a 100 gallon tank with plants that you want to cheaply and safely add moderate amounts of CO₂ to. One small mouthed bottle won’t do much as the aquarium is too large. And six to ten bottles is a little problematic. The only way is to use a system which puts a small but steady stream of CO₂ into the aquarium with something like a plastic make up jar.
To make the diffuser bottle that will safely add a moderate amount of CO₂ to an aquarium, use a large mouthed plastic jar like a make up jar.
Drill ten to twelve large holes (3/8 ths inch) on the middle diameter of the make-up jar. The amount of CO₂ which will dissolve is controlled by a combination of the size of the holes drilled, the number of holes drilled, and the water flow through the container (i.e. how close the container is to flowing water).
The more holes, the larger the holes and the more flow the faster the CO₂ will dissolve in the water of the aquarium. So start out with two to four holes and increase to where the CO₂ dissolution rate is where you want it to be. Conversely, if the CO₂ level is too high for you, simply cover one or more holes.
Put several large stones in the jar to weight it down. Then drill a hole in the jar and run a silicone CO₂ gas hose through the wall of the jar with a silicone seal. Put the cap on the jar and put it in the aquarium, top side down. This jar can be hidden behind a rock or decoration quite easily due to its low profile.
The jar can fill with CO₂ gas down to where the holes are. Excess CO₂ can vent though the four holes. Water will also SLOWLY flow in and out of the holes, picking up CO₂ as it does that. Note the above diagram is very rudimentary as Microsoft in its infinite wisdom has just changed its graphics to make it impossible to do certain operations (like make a double line) AAAAaaarrrrgghhhh I hate Microsoft!
Use a system where the CO₂ bubbles into the aquarium from a constant feed CO₂ system. This flow can be from pressurized CO₂ tanks (what I prefer), yeast system, or a citric acid/baking soda system. It can be simple 24 hour feed with a low pressure system or it can be through a timed solenoid in a pressurized system.
This replaces the diffuser in most CO₂ sets with a wide mouthed jar in the aquarium. It becomes virtually impossible to add too much CO₂ and kill any fish with a wide mouthed jar diffuser like this. The key here is that the water inside the jar is still water. And still water transferers gases very slowly. Conversely, the turbulent flow around a bubble transfers gases very rapidly.
These two systems will NOT hit over 20 ppm of CO₂ in the aquarium and will only feed low tech “green” planted aquariums. They will NOT feed a high tech planted aquariums.
Let’s do some simple math here. One PPM per 100 gallons is 0.38 grams. One ppm per 10 gallons is 0.038 grams. An 8 fluid ounce water bottle will hold 237 cubic centimeters. The density of carbon dioxide gas is 0.00195 grams per cubic centimeter. So the bottle will hold 0.462 grams of carbon dioxide.
Over one day the bottle system will put into an aquarium 0.462 grams of carbon dioxide per day. So this is about 12 ppm per day (0.462/0.038 = 12.16) added to a 10-gallon tank. This is a VERY small amount of CO₂ for one day addition with say a Tropica system 60 in even a ten gallon aquarium.
The second scenario is where one is using the wide mouth jar diffuser in an aquarium larger than 20 gallons. If one were using a sugar/yeast generation with one cup of sugar, one will get about 100 grams of CO₂ generated over two weeks. This is 100/14 or 7 grams per day added to the tank per day. In a 100 gallon aquarium this is 18 ppm per day (7/0.38 = 18.42). In a fifty gallon that is 36 ppm scattered over 24 hours.
This will give a decent growth of some low tech “green” plants. It is NOT the 30 ppm of a high tech system. It is a low enough amount that these systems are safe even running 24 hours a day with no pressure tanks, pressure valving and no solenoid if you have a citric acid/baking soda or sugar/yeast arrangement.
In general, as the price of a system goes up the operating costs go down, the amount of CO₂ going into the system is more level and the frequency of maintenance goes down. A large expensive five-pound pressurized CO₂ system can have very low operating costs and add a very well-regulated flow of CO₂ for upwards of six months on one charge.
One can contrast the efficiencies of any of the variations of this low-tech system with the various high-tech pressurized CO₂ systems which use a CO₂ diffuser that creates small bubbles to get the CO₂ into the water. The high-tech systems have an obvious problem. There is very little discernible difference between the size of a CO₂ bubble at the bottom of the tank and the size at the surface when the bubble bursts at the surface of the tank (unless one is using a “reactor”).
This would indicate that easily 30% to 50% of the CO₂ being added to the aquarium with a high-tech mister diffuser system is ending up being uselessly dissipated into the atmosphere (testing said 40%). This makes the bottle diffuser low-tech system more efficient than a bubbler and thus cheaper to operate if one can size everything properly.
Of course, the biggest difference between the two systems is safety. With a fine bubbler in a high-tech system, if the regulator sticks or drifts (a surprisingly common occurrence), there can be a whole lot of fine CO₂ bubbles put into the aquarium. This can raise the CO₂ level above 30 ppm and kill any fish in the tank. With the low tech bottle diffuser method, the excess CO₂ will simply bubble to the surface in harmless large bubbles.
Further Information on CO₂ Systems
A general treatment of carbon dioxide in the planted aquarium can be found at this link:
More information on setting up a high tech CO₂ injection system can be found at this link:
Another type of aquarium uses a wood rich soil to provide a modicum of CO₂ to an aquarium:
Yet another type of planted aquarium uses wood pellets to provide extra CO₂:
Using food to provide CO₂ is covered in this link:
Measurement of the CO₂ level in an aquarium is covered in this link:
The intricate relationship between Plants, KH, pH, and CO₂ is covered in this link:
And some additional data on the complex “Bermuda Triangle” of pH, KH, and CO₂ can be found in this link: